update 19 August 2021

Evaluation of Blockchain Consensus Algorithms

Since the dawn of the Internet, the transmission of value has always been a problem. The open nature of the Internet allows anyone to copy and propagate information without any repercussions. Because of the infrastructure that involves the transfer of packets in a predefined protocol, it is easier to copy stuff on the internet than to gulp down water. There arose a need for a protocol that could propagate with the same speed but does allow replication. A protocol for transferring value was needed.

On the face of it, a digital currency sounds impossible. Suppose some person – let us call her Alice – has some digital money that she wants to spend. If Alice can use a string of bits as money, how can we prevent her from using the same bit string repeatedly, thus minting an infinite supply of money? Alternatively, if we can somehow solve that problem, how can we prevent someone else from forging such a string of bits and using that to steal from Alice?

Bitcoin’s Proof-of-Work solved just that impossible problem. The solution was so elegant that nobody can explain why it was not thought of earlier because nothing in the solution was new. It was a mixture of everything that had already been discovered.

It did not take a lot of time for innovation to start on PoW itself. Several interesting ideas were proposed in rapid successions that either solved some more problems or cut through hassles.

“With e-currency based on cryptographic proof, without the need to trust a third party middleman, money can be secure and transactions effortless.” – Satoshi NakamotoBitcoin open-source implementation of P2P currency

Let us understand a little bit about each consensus algorithm first to decide for ourselves!

POW vs. POS vs. POI vs. dPOS

What is Proof-of-Work (POW)

By combining an authentication of work with information transfer, Satoshi Nakamoto outlined in his original Bitcoin whitepaper a system for discouraging duplication and incentivizing the gatekeepers who keep the network in check. Proof-of-Work solved multiplicity in the only remaining void that needed to be filled on the internet.

The PoW idea was originally published by Cynthia Dwork and Moni Naor back in 1993, but the term “proof of work” was coined by Markus Jakobsson and Ari Juels in a document published in 1999.

Proof of work is a consensus protocol introduced by Bitcoin and used widely by many other cryptocurrencies. This process is known as mining, and as such, the nodes on the network are known as “miners.” The “proof of work” comes in the form of an answer to a mathematical problem, one that requires considerable work to arrive at but is easily verified to be correct once the answer has been reached. The proof of work system is specifically designed to be difficult and requires considerable computing power. More and more users come in to ensure that too many Bitcoins are not mined too quickly, preserving a consistent supply and incentive for miners to maintain the network.

Essentially, the security of the network is enforced physically by specialized hardware. As such, proof of work can be seen as not being an infinitely scalable protocol since the hardware and the electricity spent to the power that hardware is limited in resources.

What is Proof-of-Stake (PoS) 

“In proof of stake, besides incentivizing honesty, dishonesty is discouraged.” – Mohit Mamoria, Is Proof of Stake the solution?

Proof of Stake takes away the energy and computational power requirement of PoW and replaces it with a stake. A stake is referred to as an amount of currency that an actor is willing to lock up for a certain amount of time. In return, they get a chance proportional to their stake to be the next leader and select the next block.

PoS uses a time-stamping method to reach a consensus about a block by betting on it. This process alone opens a variety of criticisms. Say the betting amount is said to 10,000 ABCoin, and the average holder has about 20 ABCoin. Therefore, anyone with the minimum betting requirement is bound to get richer with each block while the others wait for the chance to place a bet. Not everyone can afford to be a staker. It can be argued that over a period, the gap will become significant, and therefore, the power to influence the ABCoin network will lie in the hands of a few, not unlike the current state of the Bitcoin PoW network.

What is Proof-of-Importance (PoI)

Proof-of-Importance (PoI) can be considered as New Economic Movement’s (NEM) most standout innovation. PoI, as a reward structure, is different from Proof-of-Work and Proof-of-Stake as it removes all the perceived drawbacks that both the algorithms carry, such as mining monopolies and large stake hoarders. PoI algorithm calculates the weight of an address’s contribution to the Network, i.e., the stake, transactional history, and amount of time spent on the network. Each transaction (above a minimum size) contributes to the POI score and increases the chances of harvesting a block and collecting rewards. To relegate the risk of artificially increasing transactions and importance score by going back and forth between the same wallets, only net transfers are taken into account by the algorithm. 

Say ABC, a registered user on the NEM blockchain, has more than 10,000 vested tokens (the amount unspent and unmoved for a few weeks) transacts on the network. The Proof-of Importance algorithm ranks ABC based on his vest and traffic contributed to the network, using it to delegate the process of computing transactions, verifying the block, and collecting rewards called Delegated Harvesting. ABC’s importance also allows him to push his transactions and messages ahead of accounts with lower importance scores, meaning that PoI can also be used as a reputation metric.

Each account has a Proof of Importance (POI) score that determines its chances of harvesting a block. With delegated harvesting, ABC is lending his POI score to a remote node, increasing its chances of harvesting a block on its behalf.

What is delegated Proof-of-Stake (dPoS)

“Delegated Proof of Stake (otherwise known as DPoS) is a consensus algorithm maintaining irrefutable agreement on the truth across the network, validating transactions and acting as a form of digital democracy.” – Lisk.io

At its core, DPoS seeks to speed up transactions and block creation while not compromising the decentralized incentive structure at the heart of the blockchain. DPoS proclaims itself to be an improvement to the highly flawed Proof-of-Stake consensus mechanism.

There are three main characteristics in the DPoS system; Witness, Voting, and Delegation.

In essence, Users are asked to ‘delegate’ their ‘voting’ power to other users, whom they trust to vote for ‘witnesses’ on their behalf. By claiming that their incentives and structures enhance their blockchains’ security and integrity, and each user has an incentive to perform their role honestly, PoI proclaims its higher ground against PoW and PoS. It requires no specialized equipment to become a user, witness, or delegate. A normal computer with sufficient GPU is more than enough to take part in the campaign. Most importantly, PoI is energy efficient compared to power-hungry Proof of Work hashing algorithms.

Conclusion

This question has been the central point of a lot of fiery debate. Everyone seems to have an opinion of their own. The stage is not unlike a street fight, where members of both sides go down to calling each other names, exchanging abuses, and branding the other side as un-visionary. Most bitcoin maximalists side with PoW, recounting the game-theoretic incentive structure that it implements to solve the age-old Byzantine Generals’ Problem. Other skeptics argue that PoW isn’t worth all the energy consumption it brings along. Then, the other side proudly proclaims the simplicity and elegance of Proof-of-Stake, Proof-of-Importance, and similar concepts that implement all of PoWs infrastructure, excluding its infinite appetite for energy.

Without constructive criticism, it is not possible to move ahead and leave behind all the flaws. To side with a particular mechanism cannot be seen as the right thing to do as many intellectually capable people are behind each side. Numerous research papers, articles, and discussions have been put forward, arguing for both sides of the debate.

Experimentation had been steadily going on, such as Ethereum’s much-awaited Casper FFG, with its planned shift from PoW to PoS, making all the hardware devices dedicated to the network obsolete. It would also mean an increase in adoption, as it becomes more cost-effective to be a part of the network. Similar advancements are also being implemented by EOS, NEO, XEM, Reddcoin, and so on, trying to sway the market towards the staking mechanism. Some iterations of the algorithm, such as delegated Proof-of-Stake (dPoS) and Hybrid PoS + PoW, are also being experimented with.

Btc
Bitcoin
$61.432
price
0.30209%
price change
BUY NOW

It remains to be seen which way the market sides, which algorithm pushes itself towards the top. Nevertheless, one thing is for sure. The general audience will benefit from the community’s internal fights, bringing about greater competition and higher prospects.

More posts

Earliest Cryptocurrencies with DeFi-like Characteristics

A recent Chainalysis report shows how Europe accounts for 25% of the world's cryptocurrency transactions. The news came as a surprise to many. However, Decentralized Finance (DeFi) is the center of these crypto transactions. So, it takes about 50% of the total amount from the region's trades. DeFi is an innovative niche that many enthusiasts still have not explored fully. Nevertheless, numerous smaller crypto assets with similar characteristics to DeFi tokens already exist. Binance Chain, PancakeSwap, and Uniswap are examples…

Which Altcoins Made The News in H1 of 2021

Altcoins are constantly jostling to make a mark in the crypto world. After Bitcoin and Ethereum, the race to be the third cryptocurrency force keeps heating up every year. Many strong contenders with different use cases promise more than what the big two currently offer. As a result, many are making their mark in a big way, for good and not so good reasons, as long as they stand out from meme coins that ride the celebrity popularity wave and…

Top Altcoins with the Most Potential For 2022

In 2017, altcoins became a thing when thousands of Bitcoin competitors flooded the market. Today, many altcoins have evolved beyond expectations and are stand-alone products with unique real-world applications. Furthermore, they provide an opportunity for investors to diversify their portfolios. Identifying the best cryptocurrencies to invest in can be overwhelming for most newbies, primarily since thousands of them exist. We bet you're having difficulty finding the most promising altcoins in the crypto space. So, this article should help you get…

Institutional Investors who have Expanded their Portfolio in 2021

Cryptocurrency and blockchain investments from the first 9 months of 2021 have surpassed last year's grand total. In the first half of 2021, the worldwide crypto and blockchain activity was $8.7 million, more than double last year's figures. It is a significant sign that institutional money is streaming into the crypto space. Furthermore, it increases the investor base, and thus the institutional awareness and knowledge of this sector are also surging. The "institutional adoption" of crypto is already underway. Today…

Understanding Cardano, IOHK, and EMURGO

Cardano is the first decentralized public blockchain platform that developed on a research-first driven approach. Charles Hoskinson, the co-founder of Ethereum, created it in 2015 and later launched it in 2017. It comprises a development team of global researchers and engineers. This platform's development continued thanks to academics and computer scientists and their peer-reviewed papers. The Cardano ecosystem involves three founding entities that work together. These partners are EMURGO, IOHK Company, and The Cardano Foundation. Cardano in a Nutshell Cardano…

Billionaires Who Have Publicly Showed Interest in Cryptocurrencies

The cryptocurrency boom of 2017 saw a rise in their acceptance from prominent economic figures. Since then, their volatility hasn't stopped significant investments in them. Today there's a push for their global mass adoption. Industry-leading lights and renowned celebrities have expressed their support for the assets. Nothing best captures this reality than Forbes's recent list of the world's wealthiest people. It indicates a growth in the number of crypto billionaires over time. From an asset that courted controversy and skepticism,…

Which is the Most Crypto-Friendly Country in Europe?

When cryptocurrencies made their first appearance in the financial world, many people were skeptical about them. Governments mainly felt threatened because the digital currencies dispelled the need for central banks. A little over a decade later, cryptocurrency mainstream adoption has made strides. However, many jurisdictions remain hostile toward digital currencies.  There's no denying that cryptocurrencies present several advantages, which is why many enthusiasts and investors are jumping on board. However, for mainstream crypto adoption to go globally, jurisdictions must accept…

Crypto Signals to Stop You from Succumbing to FOMO Woes

In the case of cryptocurrency, FOMO is popular due to enormous and rapid gains. However, as more people realize these great opportunities, they are afraid that they will miss them. When you think that you can win a particular cryptocurrency, you begin to buy it in huge numbers. As numerous investors and traders believe that blockchain and crypto are in the early stages and have excellent development potential, FOMO appears to be more than just a driving force in the…

Understanding Ethereum’s Solidity Programming Language

Ethereum is a cryptocurrency capable of storing value and making payments. However, that's not all. It is also a fully-fledged platform for creating smart contracts, and this is where Solidity comes in. Solidity is a high-level language for implementing smart contracts. It gets its inspiration from C++, Python, and JavaScript and should target the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM). This article will uncover all about the Solidity programming language and how it works. But first, we'll look closer at the Ethereum…

Hedera – A Comprehensive Guide to a Revolutionary Consensus System

Blockchain is the digital environment supporting cryptocurrencies and decentralized app (DApps). You may know it as one of the greatest innovations of the 21st century. However, this remarkable invention has its shortcomings. For instance, it is difficult to scale and consumes too much energy, making it bad for the environment. Fortunately, some projects aim to solve these issues. One of them, Hedera, has come up with a potentially better alternative to blockchain: Hashgraph consensus. Consequently, Hedera used it to open…