ICO vs. STO – Understanding the Differences

As a savvy blockchain investor, it’s smart to understand the differences between an ICO vs. STO. Recently, there has been a lot of hype surrounding STOs and their ability to service institutional clientele. Here is how these unique financial instruments came to be and why so many analysts see them as the evolution of Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs).

What is an ICO? – ICO vs. STO

The first step in this journey is to understand precisely what an ICO is and what purpose it serves. ICOs are blockchain-based crowdfunding campaigns. What makes them so unique is their ability to streamline the crowdfunding process.

Before the ICOs, crowdfunding campaigns consisted of Initial public offerings (IPOs).  IPOs are the process by which a private company can go public through its stocks to the general population. The problem with IPOs is that they are expensive to host and require the company hosting the event to traverse an intensive regulatory framework. 

On average, hosting an ICO costs a company around $1 million. Additionally, there are specific requirements every company that wishes to host an IPO must follow. These regulations include publicly listing financial disclosure. Firms must also provide in-depth information regarding their executives and their network. Once you take all of these factors into account, it’s easy to see why SMEs decided to search for alternatives. 

 ICOs Eliminate these Costs

Through blockchain technology, ICOs provide a more secure and efficient means to accomplish the same goals as an IPO. Blockchain leverages transparency and real-time monitoring capabilities to ensure the network remains secure. These systems also eliminate the need for third-party verification systems.

These systems are responsible for much of the costs and delays encountered in the IPO strategy. Eliminating these concerns lowers the entry bar for startups seeking to secure public funding. Consequently, it was only a matter of time before ICOs began to take flight.

The First ICOs

The first ICO took place in July 2013. The event, hosted by the Mastercoin, demonstrated how ICOs could provide the same services as IPOs but at a fraction of the cost. In 2014, Ethereum launched an ICO that secured the network 3,700 BTC in its first 12 hours (approximately $2.3 million at the time).

2017 Break Out Year

In 2017, the entire crypto market experienced a breakout year. The value of most cryptocurrencies skyrocketed as more investors poured into the sector. At this time, it seemed as if all blockchain-centric companies were well on their way to success. However, this was not the case. 

Billions Made

Despite companies such as EOS securing billions during their ICOs, traditional investment firms and major corporations still avoided the practice. These companies felt as if the ICO sector was the wild west of investments, and the lack of an established regulatory framework left their investments open to unnecessary risks.

Sadly, many of their concerns proved to be true as scammers began to dominate the ICO sector. At one point, reports suggested that as many as 80% of the ICOs available to the public were scams. These scams resulted in billions of lost revenue. 

Regulators Step In

As the number of jolted investors increased, so did their voices demanding retribution. Eventually, regulators had no choice but to intervene. This intervention is known as the ICO crackdown. Officially, the ICO crackdown started in China after the government banned ICOs and cryptocurrency exchanges.

Over the following years, regulatory bodies such as the SEC began to go after major ICOs from 2017. These firms had to pay fines and penalties for “the illegal sales of securities.” In some instances, the firms had to refund investors fully.

Howie Test

Usually, regulators turned to the half-century-old “Howie Test” to determine if a particular digital asset fell under the strict securities guidelines currently in place globally. The Howie Test is simply a set of questions regarding a specific investment. If you answer yes to two of these questions, your investment falls under the scope of securities regulations. 

  1. It is an investment of money.
  2. There is an expectation of profits from the investment.
  3. The investment of money is in a common enterprise.
  4. Any profit comes from the efforts of a promoter or third party.

If You Can’t Beat’em, join ’em

As the regulatory climate became hostile towards ICOs, blockchain developers sought out other ways to continue to leverage blockchain technology within the crowdfunding sector. Soon it became evident that a new type of token was needed. 

What is an STO?

This token, known as a security token, would include all of the regulations required by the SEC directly in its protocols. These tokens featured advanced smart contracts that could approve and deny transactions based on their regulatory compliance. These new offerings received the name – Security Token Offerings.

What Makes STOs so Great

STOs provide traditional institutions the ability to conduct crowdfunding campaigns via the blockchain without the risk of future regulatory concerns emerging. These token can include a host of regulatory requirements. These regulations can include KYC/AML, geo-location-based restrictions, and minimum investment amounts.

Different than ICOs

Although STOs operate similarly to ICOs, they are very different in many ways. For example, in an ICO, anyone can participate from around the world. Additionally, there is little to no additional requirements to meet. In most instances, the only real concern is the ICO start and completion dates.

An STO requires a lot more work on the part of investors. Investors will need to meet all of the predefined stipulations before they can even invest in an STO. Additionally, STO investors are unable to trade their tokens to unauthorized parties. In this way, STOs retain regulatory compliance throughout the lifecycle of their tokens.

So Which is Better – ICO vs. STO?

Bitcoin live price
price change

In the end, there is no one size fits all when it comes to blockchain crowdfunding. If you live in a region with little regulatory oversight, an ICO will cost much less to host and provide you with the same opportunities as an STO. However, if you live in the US or EU, you will want to evaluate your project to see if it is wise to host an STO or an ICO based on its merits.

Stay up to date with our latest articles

More posts

An Easy Guide to Initial Gaming Offerings (IGO)

Initial Gaming Offerings, or IGOs, have been gaining in popularity as of late. This guide will explore the ins and outs of IGO investing. The aim of this post is to help you make informed decisions about this investment opportunity.  We'll cover everything from what they are and how they work to the benefits and risks associated with them. At the end of the guide, you will find it easier to assess IGOs on the market. What Are IGOs, and…

Initial Metaverse Offerings (IMO) – A Beginner’s Guide

Initial Metaverse Offerings (IMO) allow businesses to raise money by issuing tokens on the blockchain. IMO offer investors a chance to get in on the ground floor of exciting new projects. Through an IMO, you may provide businesses with the capital they need to get started.  This guide will explore what IMO are, how they work, and what you need to know before investing in one. What Are Initial Metaverse Offerings (IMO)? Initial Metaverse Offerings are a way for blockchain…

What Is Liquid Staking? A Beginner’s Guide

Liquid staking is a new way to stake your coins and earn rewards. Here we will show you how to get started with liquid staking and explain the benefits of this new system. We will also discuss the main difference between standard staking and liquid staking. What is Liquid Staking? Liquid staking is a way to earn rewards for holding tokens. You can stake your tokens and then easily withdraw them if necessary with liquid staking.  This makes it an…

Sleep Minting – A Guide to a Potential Threat for the NFT Market

Sleep minting happens when a scammer mints an NFT to a renowned creator's wallet with authorization to retrieve it. This gives the impression that creators legitimately minted an NFT to themself before sending it to a criminal. This guide will teach you how to protect yourself from sleep minting scams. Moreover, we will mention what steps you can take to prevent the phenomenon from happening. What is Sleep Minting? Scammers utilize "sleep minting” to mint an NFT and deposit it…

NFT Floor Price – A Beginner’s Guide

When you think about it, the concept of a floor price is relatively simple. It’s the price below which no one can sell an asset. In traditional finance, a centralized exchange is responsible for setting a floor price.  For example, if a stock falls below a threshold, the exchange may halt trading to prevent prices from dropping further. The same principle applies to digital assets and securities. The floor price for an NFT depends on supply and demand, historical prices,…

How Do NFT Transaction Fees Work?

When sending or receiving NFTs, you'll need to pay a fee to the blockchain to process the transaction. This fee helps to cover the costs of processing and validating the transaction. The fee varies depending on the blockchain, but it's generally small. If you're new to NFTs, then it's important to understand how transaction fees work before sending or receiving any tokens. By understanding the fees involved, you can avoid unexpected costs and make sure blockchains process your transactions smoothly.…

Buying and Selling NFTs – The Most Important Criteria to Consider

Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) are digital assets that are not interchangeable. They each have unique characteristics, making them unlike any other token on the market. For this reason, they hold a lot of potential for various industries and use cases.  In this guide, we will take a look at the most common criteria for trading NFTs. What Are NFTs? NFTs are unique digital assets and cannot be interchangeable. This feature makes them perfect for various applications, including gaming, collectibles, and online…

How to Protect Yourself from NFT Scams

As the popularity of cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology continues to grow, so does the potential for scams and fraud. In this article, we’ll go over some common threats to your safety when investing in or using non-fungible tokens (NFTs).  The guide will provide some tips on how you can protect yourself from these dangers.  The NFT Opportunity and Its Appeal to Scammers Blockchain, a decentralized ledger tracking all transactions involving an item, is where NFTs reside. NFTs can represent anything…

The Importance of Smart Contract Auditing

Smart contracts are the innovation that propelled blockchain technology to where it is today. This invention fulfills the agreement between all the parties in a deal without the need for intermediaries. As a result, it boosts the security and immutability of a blockchain network, allowing numerous and diverse applications to develop. Unfortunately, smart contracts are not flawless and could lead to million-dollar losses if hackers can exploit their tinniest loopholes. For example, some famous attacks on smart contract code glitches…

Top NFT AR Projects to Follow during the Crypto Winter

The crypto market is experiencing one of its worst “winters” in its 12-year history. Some pessimistic voices claim it's all downhill from here. However, expert traders know that the future is not as bleak as it seems. On the contrary, new and innovative projects are still surfacing in the market, giving us a glimpse of how promising the new "crypto spring" will look. Sitting and waiting for the crypto winter to pass is gruesomely depressing. That’s why we put together…