What Are Bitcoin Covenants? A Guide to a Controversial Proposal

The proposal to implement Bitcoin covenants has spurred a fiery debate in the Bitcoin community, dividing people on the subject. On the one hand, many believe that covenants could make Bitcoin safer and more scalable. Conversely, others see it as an attack on the network’s decentralized, anonymous, and censorship-free nature.

While experts unravel the implications of covenants for Bitcoin, we look closer at the proposal and how it could work. This guide to Bitcoin covenants should help clear the air if you are new to the topic.

What Are Bitcoin Covenants?

This somewhat bizarre term comes from the private property law, where a covenant is a contract restricting a commodity’s use. For example, a landlord could insert covenants in the rent contract, preventing the tenant from painting the walls in specific colors, cutting trees in the yard, etc.

In cryptocurrency, a Bitcoin covenant is a mechanism limiting the selling options that a fresh BTC owner would have over his bitcoins. For instance, it could restrict where the user can transfer those assets and how he would spend them.

Legally, Bitcoin is private property. However, even if you own BTC, certain covenants could limit how you use them. In traditional finance, banks impose covenants on particular merchants they suspect of participating in illegal activities. To this end, a Bitcoin covenant could prevent ill-intentioned users from using BTC for fraudulent operations.

Bitcoin is constantly developing and improving thanks to Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs), a standard method of promoting modifications to the Bitcoin protocol.

The concept of Bitcoin covenants first appeared in the somewhat controversial BIP119 as a soft fork. Their implementation could give BTC owners substantial benefits. For example, a covenant would prevent theft when a holder’s account is hacked.

BIP119 modifies Bitcoin’s code, enabling it to employ a new operation code (opcode), OP_CHECKTEMPLATEVERIFY (CTV-type covenant). However, it only includes a limited list of risky use cases in which the covenant would intervene. This CTV could have potential benefits for the Bitcoin network, such as increasing its scalability.

Nevertheless, implementing Bitcoin covenants is exceptionally tricky. The cryptocurrency’s resistance to censorship, external control, and 100% fungibility could prevent its fulfillment. Let’s dive deeper to see how that would pan out.

How Bitcoin Covenants Work

A Bitcoin covenant differs slightly from other restrictions the Bitcoin script language imposes. In fact, BTC holders already have to meet specific conditions and overcome limitations before completing a Bitcoin transfer. For example, a user must provide a signature confirming that the private key matches the public key of their wallet. Otherwise, they couldn’t transfer funds. Another limitation is the timelock, which could specify that coins cannot be spent until after a certain number of blocks. These conditions are part of the locking script protecting the Bitcoin network.

Covenants take these restrictions to the next level by specifying what users can do with their coins or where they can spend them. They also impose specific conditions on unspent transactions (UTXO), defining the coins’ expenditure purposes.

A BTC holder could impose a covenant on its wallet by limiting the whitelisted addresses to where the bitcoins can be spent. This way, if a hacker breaks the account, they can only send funds to those whitelisted wallets.

Benefits of Bitcoin Covenants

The Bitcoin network has struggled with various shortcomings since its early days. One is the “Bitcoin Trilemma,” the concept that a decentralized network can only provide two out of three benefits – decentralization, security, and scalability – at any time.

Covenants could help improve two of these factors, security, and scalability.

Firstly, covenants could help increase security by giving users more control over where they can transfer their assets. They could prevent theft and help implement safety vaults for enhanced end-user protection.

A Bitcoin covenant could also help holders implement pre-signed transactions. This means that hackers cannot gain complete control over their assets even if they steal and secure the wallet’s private key.

Lastly, covenants could help prevent double-spending attacks and improve Bitcoin-NG. The latter proposes a Byzantine fault-tolerant blockchain protocol that would increase the network’s scalability. Its supporters believe in Bitcoin-NG’s steady implementation as a layer over the current Bitcoin network.

Downsides of Bitcoin Covenants

While Bitcoin covenants seem like a good, maybe even necessary, improvement on paper, they did not win the community’s full support. On the contrary, the BIP119 proposal is withstanding staunch criticism from Bitcoin experts, such as Adam Back, Jimmy Song, and Andreas Antonopoulos.

The latter believes that this implementation would lead to recursive covenants. This concept refers to a programmer restricting one transaction after another, potentially leading to limitless consecutive covenants clogging the network.

Another potential downside to Bitcoin covenants is the risk of censorship, centralized control, and confiscation. Enhanced security is often why authorities choose to strengthen their control over people. In this case, a covenant could force exchange platforms to accept deposits or withdrawals only from specific wallets.

Currently, authorities can ask exchanges to send crypto assets only to addresses with taproots or government-controlled multi-sig wallets. However, a covenant could make it easier for them to obtain user data and KYC.

Bitcoin is a fungible asset. This means that each coin is identical in function and quality. Implementing covenants could change the properties of specific BTC units. This means that the cryptocurrency would not be fungible anymore, thus destroying one of the coin’s fundamental functioning conditions.

The Bottom Line

The fiery debate on Bitcoin covenants is likely to continue for many years to come. On the one hand, this concept could increase the network’s stability and help boost scalability. Furthermore, it would enhance the user’s safety and control over their assets.

Nevertheless, Bitcoin covenants can potentially negatively affect the coin and the network. Their opponents believe that implementing covenants goes against Bitcoin’s fundamentals. Countless restrictions could limit the coin’s decentralized, anonymous, and censorship-resistant nature.

Bitcoin live price
price change

Picking sides in this debate is difficult. In the end, only the users and node operators will be able to reach a consensus on whether to implement Bitcoin covenants or not.

Stay up to date with our latest articles

More posts

Ultimate Beginner Guide to Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs)

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) are essential tools in the crypto community. They allow the Bitcoin community to propose and vote on changes to the Bitcoin Core software.  BIPs can also work for other wallets/services and have a process for development and implementation. This guide will explore what BIPs are, how they work, and some of their benefits and risks. What are Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs)? Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) are proposals for changes to the Bitcoin protocol. Anyone can submit…

How Much Bitcoin Does Satoshi Nakamoto Own?

Satoshi Nakamoto – Bitcoin’s anonymous founder – may be the single largest Bitcoin whale on the planet. However, there’s no evidence that Satoshi ever has or will spend his coins. In fact, the crypto community isn’t even certain about how many coins belong to the founder. Just how rich is the father of Bitcoin? And what implications could his ancient stash have for both the network and the asset? The Patoshi Pattern One of the most popular theories to date…

What Are Bitcoin Covenants? A Guide to a Controversial Proposal

The proposal to implement Bitcoin covenants has spurred a fiery debate in the Bitcoin community, dividing people on the subject. On the one hand, many believe that covenants could make Bitcoin safer and more scalable. Conversely, others see it as an attack on the network’s decentralized, anonymous, and censorship-free nature. While experts unravel the implications of covenants for Bitcoin, we look closer at the proposal and how it could work. This guide to Bitcoin covenants should help clear the air…

Intel’s Blockscale – A New Bitcoin Mining Chip

Earlier this month, Intel announced Blocksale ASIC, the company's second-generation Bitcoin mining chip. Intel plans to deliver the new chip for the third quarter, which it claims will be more energy-efficient. What does this news mean for Intel and the blockchain sector? How will Bitcoin miners react? Intel’s Second Attempt to Attract Crypto Miners Intel's first mining chip, named Bonanza Mine, is a 7nm process packed in lots of 300. We can speak of a 3,600W mining machine with up…

SegWit2x – What is It and How Does It Work?

SegWit2x (“B2X” or “S2X”) was a failed controversial Bitcoin hard fork effort aimed to double the block size limit. Some people in the BTC community went as far as to label this proposal as a “Corporate Takeover”. Over 80% of miners supported SegWit2x, but the community could not agree on the upgrade. There are several things we can all learn from this story, as we will explain in the article. The difference between a “Soft Fork” and a “Hard Fork”…

SegWit (Segregated Witness) – What Is It and How Does It Work?

From Satoshi Nakamoto's historic whitepaper to modern times, the world of cryptocurrencies has changed a lot. This sector has brought about a real revolution in the world economy in just under ten years. Not everyone knows that the algorithm created following Nakamoto's paper has undergone several changes over time. This software (known as "Bitcoin Core") has shown more rigidity than many modern blockchains. For this reason, analyzing one of its significant changes over time is an exciting aspect. Therefore, this…

What Is a Bitcoin Node? A Guide for Beginners

How to evaluate the security of a cryptocurrency? One could easily claim that secure cryptos need to run on a secure blockchain. However, this theoretical statement can have complex applications in the real world. One way to look at the matter is by connecting security to validation. Every blockchain must have a suitable transaction validation mechanism. When it comes to blockchain validation, we generally mention nodes. Today we will talk about Bitcoin nodes. The article aims to explain a very…

Where Can You Pay Taxes With Bitcoin?

Short-term Bitcoin traders have an acute interest in how they can dodge paying taxes on their Bitcoin, especially on capital gains. Others see it as a tool for evading taxation altogether, including income tax. These strategies are usually quite difficult in practice and therefore NOT recommended. However, a more interesting question – relevant to law-abiders and long-term HODLers – is how we can use our Bitcoin to help pay our taxes. Directly. This prospect is essential for people who store…

The Story Of Bitcoin And Ethereum’s Reversed Blockchains

Decentralization is the primary selling point of the three worlds of Bitcoin, crypto, and the web. There are several reasons for this. Some are related to the increased transactional efficiency that decentralization can provide. Others are related to creating permissionless, censorship-resistant digital networks. The most important is that decentralization weakens any single-point-of-failure, hence bolstering network security. This not only keeps a network as close to unbiased and ‘neutral’ as possible but almost guarantees its immutability. Yet the crypto world hasn’t…

What Is A Bitcoin ETF?

On October 19th, 2021, the first Bitcoin US Bitcoin ETF launched on the New York Stock Exchange. This was a long-awaited event for the crypto community, which viewed it as a significant milestone for the industry. The debut was hyper-successful, too. Within just a day, the ETF generated over $800 million in trading volume. It was the second most lucrative stock market debut ever on the NYSE, behind Black Rock’s carbon fund. Why the enthusiasm? What is a Bitcoin ETF,…